Experience the Best of Goat Hill
We have closed for the season. Thank you to all our patrons, see you in May!
To book private events please call 631-749-1446
We have closed for the season. Thank you to all our patrons, see you in May!
To book private events please call 631-749-1446
"A Shelter Island institution with local integrity, excellent service, and delicious food. It's a great spot for families or date nights - with peaceful views of the golf course and bay. "
- Chelsea B.
"The 1901 Grill was amazing! We had a great dinner with friends, filled with delicious food, great service, tasty drinks, and a fun atmosphere. With beautiful scenic views overlooking the island, I would highly recommend it."
- Corey S.
"Best smash burger ever. Great atmosphere and friendliest staff. Stunning backdrop - we love it here."
- Rachel K.
Call or visit us during normal business hours!
Lunch Friday - Sunday 12-3pm
Dinner Service Friday- Saturday 5-8:30pm
Sunday 5- 8pm
Mon | Closed | |
Tue | Closed | |
Wed | Closed | |
Thu | Closed | |
Fri | Closed | |
Sat | Closed | |
Sun | Closed |
The 1901 Grill
26 Sunnyside Avenue Shelter Island Heights, New York 11965
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.